Creatine Supplements: Myths + Misconceptions Dispelled

Creatine supplements are one of the most popular health supplements utilized by InsideTracker users and the general population. And it’s also one of the most controversial.

While some hail it as a useful tool to increase muscle gains, boost recovery, and surge testosterone, others denounce it as an ineffective supplement that causes liver and kidney damage. Where does the real answer lie?

Before we sort out the impact creatine supplementation has on the body and how it may increase your gains or inflict stomach cramping, we need to sort out the science behind it.

What is creatine?

Creatine, which is technically known as “creatine monohydrate,” is a small, nitrogen-containing organic acid that is found naturally in humans and other vertebrates.

Creatine is not an essential nutrient—the body produces it organically without ingesting food. It is naturally produced by the kidney and liver using the amino acids glycine and arginine.

About 95% of the human’s body creatine is found in skeletal muscles—the muscles involved in body movements such as the biceps or quadriceps. [1] Overall, about 1% of blood content is composed of creatine. [1]

In the body, creatine is commonly found in one of two forms:

• It can be attached to a high-energy molecule called a phosphate group, where it is known as “creatine phosphate.”
• The second form, called “creatinine,” is a breakdown product of creatine that is then excreted by the body.

Creatine’s main function is to supply energy to cells in the body, especially those in muscle tissue, by increasing the production of the body’s primary energy molecule called “Adenosine Triphosphate” (ATP).

When producing ATP, creatine phosphate loses its phosphate group and transforms into creatine monohydrate. It is eventually broken down into creatinine and excreted by urine. Thus, creatine phosphate is the main driver of the substance’s effects on the body.

A brief history of creatine

• In 1832, French scientist Michel Eugene Chevreul discovered creatine in the body by isolating a water extract from skeletal muscle. [1]
• In 1912, two Harvard researchers found evidence that ingesting creatine can dramatically increase the amount of creatine monohydrate in the body. [2] This eventually led to the discovery of creatine phosphate in the late 1920s.
• Despite its discovery in the early 20th century, creatine wasn’t taken as a performance-enhancing supplement formally until the 1990s when the New York Times reported several medal-winning athletes used it in the 1992 Olympic Games.
• In 2014, Americans spent over $14 million dollars on 4 million kilograms of creatine supplements. [3]

Science behind creatine supplementation and its impact on performance and health

Ever since its increase in prevalence, creatine supplementation has been mired in controversy. While it is not considered to be a performance-enhancing drug, people wonder: Is it safe? Can it make you stronger and less fatigued? Does it boost your endurance? Can it increase testosterone? Some even wonder: Does it affect your heart health?

Below, we investigate the research and how you can use your blood data from an InsideTracker analysis to answer all of these questions.

» Find out why women should care about testosterone

Is creatine safe for the kidneys and liver?

Creatine supplements are most often associated with throwing your internal biochemistry out of balance and ultimately damaging your kidneys, liver, and blood. However, what does the research say about the toxicity of creatine in your body?

In a 2002 study, researchers recruited 23 members of an NCAA Division 2 American football team. These subjects were all males aged 19-24 with at least two years of strength-training experience.

• The first group of ten subjects consumed between 5g and 20g of creatine monohydrate/per day from 0.25 years to 5.6 years.
• The second group of 13 took no supplements prior to the study.

Researchers assessed both groups’ levels of liver enzymes, alanine aminotransferase (ALT) and aspartate aminotransferase (AST), which are both indicative of toxicity within the body and measured in InsideTracker’s ultimate panels.

Additionally, scientists measured substances indicative of toxicity such as urea, alkaline phosphatase, and albumin, which is also measured by InsideTracker. When assessing the results, researchers noted that correlations between these substances and consumption of supplementation were nonsignificant. As a result, the researchers concluded that:



In 2001, researchers assessed the effects of regular supplementation on athletes in a retrospective study. To do this, scientists recruited twenty-six athletes, 18 males and 8 females, from various sports with a median age of 24.7 years and a body weight of 82.4 kg.

Seven of these subjects reported no use of creatine, nine reported using it regularly for up to one year, and ten reported using it for 1-4 years.

Blood was collected between 7:00 AM and 8:30 AM after a 12-hour fast. They evaluated levels of testosterone, cortisol, and growth hormone. Additionally, they asked subjects to answer a questionnaire on their history of creatine supplementation, medical history, training, and perceived effects of supplementation.

When the researchers examined the data, they noted differences in creatinine and total protein. All means of biomarkers were within healthy clinical ranges. There were also no noted differences in the incidence of muscle injury, cramps, and other side effects. Collectively, “this data suggests that long-term creatine supplementation does not result in adverse health effects.” [5]

How much creatine should you take?

It is important to take the proper amount of creatine—this means that when “loading” creatine, you should take no more than 0.3 g/kg/day for a week. Then, once muscles have reached saturation, take no more than 5-6 grams/day of creatine. [6]

If you have a history of kidney or liver illness, do not take creatine.

Does creatine actually make you stronger?

When used properly, creatine supplements are a useful performance-enhancing supplement. However, do they actually improve your athletic performance?

In 2003, sports physiologists sought to assess the effects of healthy creatine supplementation on muscle strength and weightlifting performance by conducting a meta-analysis of 22 high-quality research studies. When reviewing the literature, they paid special attention to gender, individual variability, and training history.

Effects of healthy creatine supplementation on muscle strength

On average, the increase in muscle strength as evaluated by 1, 3, or 10 repetitions maximum following creatine supplementation plus resistance training was 20% from baseline. In contrast, the average increase in muscle strength following placebo ingestion was 12%. This represents an 8% difference. [7]

Effects of creatine on weightlifting performance

Furthermore, the average increase in weightlifting performance as measured by the maximum number of repetitions at a given percent of maximal strength, increased by 26% in subjects that regularly consumed creatine supplements and regularly performed resistance training. In contrast, strength increased only by 12% in subjects who regularly consumed placebo supplementation along with regular resistance training. [7]

Among the studies, the increase in bench press 1 repetition maximum ranged from 3% to 45%, while improvement in weightlifting performance in the bench press ranged from 16% to 43%. [7]

Because of these findings, the authors of the meta-analysis stated that “…there is substantial evidence to indicate that creatine supplementation during resistance training is more effective at increasing muscle strength and weightlifting performance than resistance training alone.” [7]

However, they acknowledged the variability of the results in the studies and emphasized that the response is “highly variable.” [7]



A more recent study from 2011 assessed the impact of creatine supplementation dosage and frequency on muscle size and strength from resistance training in young adults.

Researchers recruited 38 physically active, untrained university students aged 21-28 years and divided them into four different groups for a six-week-long study.

• The first group of eleven subjects were asked to consume 0.15 grams of creatine/kg of body weight for 2 days/week for six weeks. They performed 3 sets of 10 repetitions of each exercise for resistance training 2 days/week.
• The second group of 11 subjects were asked to consume 0.10 grams of creatine/kg of body weight 3 days a week. They participated in the same resistance training exercise as the first group.
• The third group of 8 subjects served as a placebo for the first group.
• The fourth group of 8 subjects served as a placebo for the second group.

Before and after training, researchers took measurements of muscle thickness, 1 repetition maximum for leg press and chest press, and kidney function.

When evaluating key strength and muscle metrics, researchers noted that strength and muscle gains improved in all subjects. However, increases in muscle thickness were more pronounced in the two groups that took creatine supplements (20% and 16.5% increase) than the two groups that didn’t take creatine (2.3% and 6.3% increase).

Additionally, men supplementing with creatine experienced greater improvement in leg press strength compared to women supplementing with creatine (62% vs 34%). The researchers noted no statistically significant differences between the groups that took creatine at different frequencies.

As a result of these findings, researchers concluded that “Creatine supplementation during resistance training has a small beneficial effect on regional muscle thickness in young adults, but that giving the creatine over 3 days/week did not differ from giving the same dose over 2 days/week.” [8]

Does creatine lower fatigue?

In a 2011 study, researchers recruited 22 healthy men and women with an average age of 21 years.

• They randomized 10 of them to take 0.03 g of creatine per 1 kg of body weight for 6 weeks.
• The other 10 participants were asked to consume an equivalent weight and frequency of placebo.

The experiment was double-blind and placebo-controlled, meaning that the researchers and subjects did not know who received which supplementation. Scientists measured key metrics before and after the intervention such as body composition, maximal strength, and creatine concentration in blood. The researchers also measured muscle fatigue by having them perform five consecutive sets of 30 concentric knee extensions at 180 degrees.

When assessing the key fitness metrics after the study’s six-week conclusion, the researchers noted no significant difference in body mass, lean mass, body fat percentage, or total body water in either group before and after the intervention.

Interestingly, the subjects who took creatine supplements were more resistant to fatigue during the sets. More specifically, they had 7% lower fatigue after set 2, 9% lower fatigue after the 3rd and 4th sets, and 11% lower after the 5th set. [9] In contrast, the placebo-controlled subjects experienced no significant improvement in fatigue resistance.

Additionally, you can use blood analysis to determine if creatine affects key metrics of fatigue measured by InsideTracker such as creatine kinase, c-reactive protein, and cortisol.

Another study evaluated the effects of creatine supplementation on biomarkers associated with overtraining. In 2012, Brazilian researchers recruited 25 male soccer players with an average age of 17 years old and randomly assigned them to one of two groups.

• The first group consumed 0.3 g/kg of creatine for seven days.
• The second group consumed 0.3 g/kg of placebo tablets for seven days.

The subjects were asked to participate in six 35-meter sprints at maximum speed with 10 seconds of rest between them. Blood samples were collected prior to sprints, just after the completion, and one hour after completion.

When observing indicators of inflammation after the supplementation, researchers noted that there were significant increases in C-reactive protein (CRP) and plasma tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) in the subjects who consumed the placebo supplement one hour after their sprints. In contrast, the subjects who consumed daily creatine supplementation had no measurable increases in CRP or TNF-alpha one hour after their sprint tests. According to the authors, “These novel findings suggest that creatine has anti-inflammatory effects.” [10]

From Cooper et. al



Use InsideTracker blood analysis to see if creatine supplementation helps you lower levels of inflammation after strenuous training such as CRP, cortisol, and creatine kinase

Does creatine increase your endurance?

Creatine supplements make you stronger and might help you deal with overtraining. But how does it affect your aerobic endurance?

One study from 2003 indicates not too much. In it, sports scientists recruited 19 athletic, non-vegetarian subjects with an average age of 21. They divided them into two separate groups.

• The first one of 9 subjects consumed 20 grams of creatine supplements per day for the first five days during the loading phase. Then, they consumed 2 grams of creatine per day for the next six weeks.
• The other 10 subjects consumed the same mass of placebo supplement for the same frequency and duration as the other group.

To assess aerobic capacity and cardiovascular fitness, researchers had the subjects engage in an exercise regimen where they participated in cycling for three 20-minute sessions at 40%, 50%, and 60% of their aerobic capacity. In order to quantify endurance, the subjects’ blood was assessed for levels of fat and carbohydrate oxidation.

The researchers had the subjects also engage in a 20 minute cycling time trial in which they attempted to cycle for the greatest distance possible. Each of these tests was conducted before and after the intervention.

When examining the results, scientists observed that there were no statistically significant differences in endurance capacity after the intervention. [11] Additionally, there were no noted differences in the average distances covered in the time trial in both groups after their respective interventions. [11] As a result, the researchers indicated that creatine supplementation does not significantly impact aerobic endurance. [11]

Few other high-quality studies have been conducted assessing the effects of creatine supplementation on endurance metrics. One study, by Thompson et. al from 1996, reported no significant effects of six weeks of creatine supplementation (2 grams/day) in the aerobic endurance of female swimmers. [12]

Does creatine increase testosterone?

If creatine makes you stronger and boosts recovery, does it also increase your testosterone—a hormone crucial for optimal health and performance in both men and women?

In a 2006 study, researchers measured the effects of creatine and creatine plus beta-alanine, a popular muscle enhancer, on metrics of power, strength, body composition, and hormone levels.

Scientists recruited 33 male subjects and randomly assigned them to one of three groups.

• The first group consumed creatine.
• The second group consumed creatine plus beta-alanine.
• The third group consumed a placebo.

All three groups were asked to participate in regular resistance training as well.

In the subjects that took only the creatine supplement, their testosterone concentrations increased from 20.0 nmol/L to 24.4 nmol/L. This is equivalent to 577 ng/dL to 704 ng/dL.13 This change is statistically significant and represents a 22% increase. No other statistically significant changes were noted in hormone levels in any of the three groups before and after the intervention.

However, researchers also noted that the testosterone-to-cortisol ratio—a key metric of recovery measured in InsideTracker’s Ultimate Plan—increased from 52.4 prior to the intervention to 66.4 after the intervention. [13] The scientists couldn’t explain entirely why these differences and trends were observed.



In 2009, South African researchers recruited 20 male college-aged rugby players and assessed the impacts of creatine supplementation on testosterone and DHT levels in a double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover study lasting a total of 9 weeks.

Researchers divided the subjects into two groups of 10.

• The first group of 10 served as the intervention group and consumed 25 grams/day of creatine along with 25 grams/day of glucose for the first week. Then, for the next two weeks, they consumed 5 grams of creatine per day with 25 grams of glucose per day.
• The second group of 10 served as the placebo and consumed 50 grams/day of glucose for one week. Then, they consumed 30 grams of glucose per day for the next six weeks.

Both groups were then asked to participate in a 6-week “washout period” where they consumed no supplements.

After seven days of creatine loading, or a further 14 days of regular-dose creatine supplementation, testosterone levels in these subjects did not change.

However, levels of the more active form of testosterone, DHT, increased by 56% after 7 days of creatine loading and remained 40% above baseline after 14 days of maintenance. [14] Additionally, the ratio of DHT:T increased by 36% after one week of creatine supplementation and remained elevated by 22% after the maintenance dose. [14]

The researchers stated that “Creatine supplementation may, in part, act through an increased rate of conversion of testosterone to DHT.” [14] Thus, creatine may not lead to a measurable increase in testosterone levels but instead exert its effects by converting testosterone to a more active form.

If undergoing a resistance-training regimen and taking creatine supplements, use InsideTracker to see how creatine affects your testosterone levels.

Optimize your wellness and performance

Read the review

Learn More

Test

48 blood and dozens of genetic biomarkers

---

Pricing

Ultimate Plan: $699/test

---

Insurance

FSA/HSA (partial)

---

Privacy

HIPAA and SOC-2 protection

Brief overview

InsideTracker is a personalized health and wellness platform that aims to help people optimize their biomarkers to live healthier and longer lives. It analyzes genetics, behaviors, and goals to give you personalized nutrition, fitness, sleep, stress, and supplementation recommendations.

Why choose InsideTracker

InsideTracker offers DNA testing for dozens of genetic fitness, nutrition, and longevity genetic markers. Since genetics influence many aspects of your health, the app can provide helpful context and an action plan. It also integrates with wearable devices to collect real-time health data, tracking factors like sleep, activity, and heart rate.

Pros and cons

Science-backed recommendations

Comprehensive blood biomarker testing

DNA testing

Integration with wearables

Encourages retesting every 3 to 6 months

User-friendly interface

Personalized optimal zones

Customizable Action Plan

Not a replacement for medical care

DNA testing not available outside of the U.S.



How does creatine affect your cholesterol?

While the bulk of research has focused on creatine supplementation’s impact on athletic performance, a couple of studies have observed how it affects biomarkers associated with cardiovascular health.

Creatine and total cholesterol

In a 1996 study, researchers recruited 18 men and 16 women with total cholesterol concentration above 200 mg/dL. These subjects received either a supplement of creatine monohydrate (5 g of creatine and 1 g of glucose) or a placebo (6 g of glucose) for 8 weeks.

Initially, each supplement was taken orally four times per day for five days. Then, for the remaining 51 days, the supplement was taken twice a day. Researchers measured blood samples before the intervention, 4 weeks after the intervention, at the completion of the study (8 weeks), and 4 weeks after the study’s completion (12 weeks).



When measuring triglycerides, researchers noted that their triglycerides decreased by 23% and 22% at weeks 4 and 8, respectively. [15]

At week 12, both triglycerides were 26% lower than their initial levels. [15] Interestingly, males who consumed creatine supplements had reduced levels of blood glucose (though this was not statistically significant). [15] In contrast, the subjects who took the placebo did not experience similar benefits in triglycerides or glucose.

There were no statistically significant differences in LDL-C (generic “bad cholesterol”), HDL-C (“good cholesterol”), glucose, body mass, body mass index, or physical activity within or between the experimental and placebo groups. [15]

It is important to note that there was a small, but statistically significant increase in urea nitrogen in women between baseline (11.8 mg/dl) and week 8 (13.8 mg/dl).15 While this isn’t a big concern for most people, if you have a history of kidney issues then creatine supplements may be harmful. Because of these findings, researchers remarked: “This preliminary data suggests that creatine monohydrate may modulate lipid metabolism in certain individuals.” [15]

Creatine and lipid levels

In a 2008 study, researchers assessed the effects of creatine supplementation on lipid levels in male subjects with healthy levels of lipids. They recruited 22 subjects and randomly divided them into two groups.

• The first group of 12 subjects received 20 grams of creatine per day for one full week followed by 10 grams of creatine per day for the next 11 weeks. They were of a healthy weight and had an average BMI of 23.2 kg/m2, had an average body fat content of 17.3%, and an average age of 24.4 years old.
• The other group of 10 subjects took an equivalent mass supplement of dextrose which served as a placebo. They were also of a healthy weight and had an average BMI of 24.1 kg/m2, average body fat content of 17.6%, and average age of 24.2 years.

Both groups of subjects participated in moderate-intensity aerobic exercise for three 40-minute sessions per week for a total of 12 weeks and had the same diet. Researchers assessed key lipids of cardiovascular health in the subjects’ blood including HDL-C, LDL-C, total cholesterol, and triglycerides before the intervention, 4 weeks after the intervention, 8 weeks after the intervention, and at the conclusion of the 12-week trial.

At the end of the 12 weeks, both groups of subjects had improved in both groups. However, there were no differences between the two groups, and these benefits were attributed to the aerobic exercise regimen.

As a result of these findings, the researchers stated that “Creatine supplementation did not have any additive effect on the plasma lipid profile of healthy sedentary males undergoing moderate-intensity aerobic training for 3 months.” [16]

However, they emphasized how the subjects in this study had primarily been conducted in subjects with normal levels of cholesterol while those in Earnest et. al were conducted primarily in subjects with high levels of cholesterol.

If your levels of lipids are elevated, and you would like to increase your strength, use your InsideTracker results to see if creatine supplementation helps manage your lipids. Creatine supplementation is unlikely to decrease lipids further if your levels of lipids are already at a healthy level.

Get the most out of creatine supplements

Creatine is one of the most controversial supplements out there, and the internet has certainly fueled the ammo for both sides. But, hopefully, we straightened out some of the creatine confusion for you. Here are some final things to keep in mind:

• Check with your doctor to see if you have healthy kidneys and liver, and choose a trusted creatine supplement brand.
• Generally, creatine supplements are taken at 20 grams/day for seven days in what is called the “loading phase” followed by 5 grams of supplement per day after this phase.
• Lastly, make sure to measure fitness metrics to see if creatine supplementation impacts your strength and endurance performance—while InsideTracker will measure key biomarkers of health and performance on the inside to see how it affects you. At the end of the day, creatine holds promise—but your data will let you know it’s the right choice for you.

References:

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16744118/

[2] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S002192581888766X

[3] https://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/druginfo/natural/873.html

[4] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12500988/

[5] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11224803/

[6] http://www.menshealth.com/fitness/creatine-101

[7] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14636102/

[8] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21512399/

[9] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20591625/

[10] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22817979/

[11] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12546637/

[12] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8889115/

[13] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17136944/

[14] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19741313/

[15] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8774269/

[16] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18831767/